Defined Benefit Plan Minimum Required Years [3 + 5 Year Limit]

Defined benefit plans are probably our favorite tax and retirement structure. But what is the minimum required years a plan has to be open? Is there a 3 or 5-year limit?

This post will address these questions and tell you a little about IRS plan permanency. While you should have long-term intent, there are ways to mitigate your risk.

The IRS rules can be complex, but we will help you navigate them. Hopefully, you can determine if a plan works well for your business.

Looking to Get $100,000+ Into Retirement?

We'll show you the #1 tax and retirement strategy!

Quick Links:

How does a defined benefit plan work?

A defined benefit plan is a company-sponsored retirement plan that provides a retirement benefit to eligible employees. It operates by calculating the retirement benefits based on a formula established in the plan document. The formula considers several factors such as the employee’s compensation history, service years, and expected retirement age. The employer is responsible for funding and administering the plan.

Once an employee meets the plan’s eligibility criteria and becomes a participant, the plan accumulates retirement benefits on their behalf. The benefit grows over time, typically through a combination of annual contributions made by the employer and investment earnings on those contributions. The employer must assume all the investment risk and ensure that the plan’s assets are sufficient to meet the future benefits.

Upon reaching retirement age, participants are entitled to receive their defined benefit payments for the rest of their lives. The benefit amount is usually a fixed monthly payment, calculated based on the predetermined formula.

Unlike defined contribution plans, where the benefit amount depends on the value of the individual account, defined benefit plans provide a stable and predictable income stream throughout the retiree’s lifetime. The plan’s financial stability is crucial, requiring careful management of investments, actuarial assumptions, and compliance with regulatory requirements to ensure the ability to fulfill the promised benefits to retirees.

Defined Benefit Plan Minimum Required Years

The IRS does not explicitly state that a defined benefit plan must be a permanent plan. However, the nature of a defined benefit plan suggests that it is intended to be a long-term, ongoing arrangement rather than a temporary or short-term program.

Top heavy defined benefit plans are required to provide a minimum benefit of 2% of W2 compensation annually for 10 years. The company must only provide this minimum benefit to non-key employees who participate in the DB plan.

When we refer to a defined benefit plan as a “permanent plan,” it generally means that it is established with the intention of providing retirement benefits to employees for an extended period. It implies that the plan is intended to be maintained indefinitely, subject to any necessary adjustments or modifications to ensure its financial sustainability and compliance with legal requirements.

Looking to Get $100,000+ Into Retirement?

We’ll show you the #1 tax and retirement strategy!

Unlike defined contribution plans, such as 401(k) plans, where the benefits are based on individual account balances, defined benefit plans typically provide a predetermined benefit formula based on factors like years of service, salary history, and age. These plans are designed to provide a specified level of retirement income to eligible participants.

While a defined benefit plan can be amended or terminated under certain circumstances, such decisions usually require careful consideration, legal compliance, and may involve providing appropriate notice and benefits to participants.

It’s important to note that the specifics of defined benefit plans, including their permanence or potential for termination, can be influenced by various factors, including legal and regulatory requirements, financial considerations, collective bargaining agreements, and the employer’s business circumstances.

Does the IRS require that a defined benefit plan be open for at least 5 years?

No, the IRS does not have a specific requirement that a defined benefit plan must be open for at least 5 years. The IRS does have rules and regulations regarding the establishment and operation of qualified retirement plans, including defined benefit plans, but there is no minimum duration specified. The IRS says that the plan should have long-term intent and be open for at least several years.

The IRS focuses on other requirements to ensure the qualified status of a defined benefit plan. These requirements include factors such as:

  1. Adequate funding: The plan must be adequately funded to meet its future benefit obligations, as determined by actuarial calculations and IRS guidelines.
  2. Nondiscrimination: The plan must meet certain nondiscrimination rules, ensuring that the benefits provided to highly compensated employees are not disproportionately favorable compared to those provided to non-highly compensated employees.
  3. Vesting: The plan must have vesting provisions that outline when and how employees become entitled to the benefits accrued under the plan.
  4. Compliance with contribution and benefit limits: The plan must adhere to the IRS-imposed contribution and benefit limits to maintain its qualified status.

While there is no specific minimum duration requirement, it is generally expected that a defined benefit plan will be maintained for a significant period to fulfill its purpose of providing retirement benefits to participants. However, the decision to establish, maintain, or terminate a defined benefit plan ultimately rests with the employer, subject to applicable legal requirements and employee rights.

It’s important to consult with a qualified pension professional or tax advisor to ensure compliance with the specific rules and regulations set forth by the IRS and other relevant authorities when establishing or operating a defined benefit plan.

Balance CalculationAmount
Beginning of year$40,000
Interest crediting rate (ICR)5%
Pay credit40% of comp
End of year$82,000

Final thoughts

In conclusion, the IRS does not explicitly require that a defined benefit plan be a permanent plan with a specific minimum duration. Instead, the focus of the IRS is on ensuring the compliance and qualified status of the plan.

While defined benefit plans are generally intended to be long-term commitments, providing retirement benefits to employees over an extended period, they can be amended or terminated under certain circumstances. The permanency of a defined benefit plan is influenced by factors such as legal requirements, financial considerations, and the employer’s business circumstances.

It is crucial for employers to understand and adhere to the rules and regulations set forth by the IRS regarding defined benefit plans. Seeking guidance from pension experts or legal professionals familiar with the relevant regulations can help ensure compliance and appropriate management of the plan.

Paul Sundin

Get a FREE 30 Minute Consultation

Reach out to us today and we'll show you our favorite strategies! We can show you how to structure a plan for maximum tax benefit and provide you with a custom plan design.

Leave a Comment