Defined Benefit Plan Vs. 401(K): Which One is Right for You?

Looking to Get $100,000+ Into Retirement?

We'll show you the #1 tax and retirement strategy!

Defined Benefit and 401k plans are both retirement savings options that have been created to help employees save for their future. However, these plans are very different and have different features that make them unique. This article will discuss each plan’s pros and cons and help you determine which is right for you.

Defined Benefit Plan (DBP) 

A Defined Benefit Plan, also often known as a traditional pension plan, is a retirement savings plan that an employer sponsors. This type of plan provides a guaranteed income to the employee after they retire. The employer is responsible for contributing to the plan, and the employee’s retirement benefits are based on a formula that considers their years of service and salary history.


  1. Guaranteed Income: DBPs provide the employee a guaranteed income after retiring. This means the employee can rely on a steady income stream even if their investment returns are poor.
  2. Employer Contributions: In a DBP, the employer is responsible for contributing to the plan, so the employee does not have to worry about funding the plan themselves.
  3. Predictable Benefit: The Benefit received from a DBP is predictable, based on a formula that considers the employee’s years of service and salary history.


  1. Limited Portability: DBPs are not portable, which means that if the employee changes jobs, they will not be able to take their benefits with them.
  2. Limited Investment Options: DBPs typically offer limited investment options, so the employee may need help choosing the investments they want.
  3. Dependent on Employer: The employee’s benefits depend on the employer, so if the employer goes bankrupt or discontinues the plan, the employee may lose their benefits.

401k plan 

A 401k Plan is a type of retirement savings plan that an employer sponsors. The employee contributes to the plan, and the employer may also contribute. The money in the plan grows tax-free until it is withdrawn, and the employee is responsible for making investment decisions.


  1. Portability: 401k plans are portable, meaning that employees can take their benefits with them if they change jobs.
  2. Investment Options: 401k plans offer a wide range of options so the employee can choose suitable investments.
  3. Employer Contributions: Some employers contribute to their employees’ 401k plans, which can help the employee save more for their future.


  1. No Guaranteed Income: 401k plans do not provide a guaranteed income, so the employee may have to rely on their investment returns to support themselves in retirement.
  2. Self-Funded: The employee is responsible for funding their 401k plan, so they may have to save more to ensure that they have enough money for their future.
  3. Market Risk: The employee’s investments in a 401k plan are subject to market risk, so their savings can be impacted if the market performs poorly.

Conclusion Defined Benefit and 401k plans are both valuable retirement savings options, but they are very different. DBPs provide a guaranteed income but are not portable and offer limited investment options. 401k plans are portable, provide a wide range of investment options, and allow employees to have more control over their investments, but they do not offer a guaranteed income.

Paul Sundin

Get a FREE 30 Minute Consultation

Reach out to us today and we'll show you our favorite strategies! We can show you how to structure a plan for maximum tax benefit and provide you with a custom plan design.

Leave a Comment